Sunday, March 18, 2012

What We Want

I used to think that what we like and want is a deeply personal thing.  That it is something we think about and on which we make a conscious decision.  But after having lived in India for about 2 months, I'm realizing that is not at all the case.

When one arrives in India, it is immediately apparent that behavioral norms, customs, processes, priorities, and aspirations are very different than in the western hemisphere.  That's expected.  But what's interesting is that they like it that way.

For example, let's take a conversation I just had last night.  Where I come from, it is every kid's dream to move out on their own as soon as they become a young adult.  They want their own place and general independence.  In India, that would be viewed as disowning one's family and is thus a very negatively perceived practice.  But young people here want to stay with their families, oftentimes even after they are married.

So what's going on here?  How can one entire society want one thing and another want the opposite?  If what we want is indeed a personal choice, this is not what we would expect.  We would expect a random distribution within each society.

The only reasonable explanation is that what we want is really not our own decision but is largely shaped by our environment.  Perhaps we do have some flexibility within that framework, but we like the framework as a whole because it is what we are used to.

Is this a good thing or a bad thing?  I'm going to go out on a limb and say it's a bad thing.  In fact, I'll generalize and say that anytime we choose something implicitly, without truly thinking about it, it's a bad thing.  And that is exactly what we are doing when we choose to like something simply because our environment tells us it's the norm.  

Let me be clear: I am not saying that one or the other view in my example above is good or bad.  I'm saying it's bad to choose one simply because our environment tells us to.

There are some people who buck the trend of choosing to like what their environment dictates.  These are generally viewed as pioneers, visionaries and revolutionaries.  Sometimes they are viewed as heretics and terrorists.  This viewpoint, too, is often determined by the environment.

After arriving here, I was forced to examine for myself why I like or want certain things.  What I found was that I, too, had implicitly chosen things based on what my society expected.  I also found that, even after realizing such, it is a very difficult thing to change what I like and want.  Perhaps I haven't yet encountered sufficient reason to do so.  Not sure.

So what is the point?  I'm afraid I don't really have one.  But I think it's important to realize the depth at which our society can shape us.  At least for me, it is deeper than I thought.

Tuesday, February 7, 2012

Crossing the Street in an Indian City

... is not for the faint of heart.  And today, my friends, I learned that I am faint of heart.

The best way I can describe it is like a real-life version of Frogger.  I really wanted to record a video of my adventure, but I decided that would be putting my life at extra risk.  

You know how in the US, drivers generally try to stay around 4-6 feet away from pedestrians?  Well, here, it's not feet, it's inches.  And it's not 4-6, it's 0.  It's like they calculate exactly where they need to be to just barely not run you over.  So you better hope you don't trip or hesitate for a second.

Also, in the US, I always assumed that if I wasn't doing anything wrong, I could safely ignore people honking their horn.  So, suffice it to say, I ignored it pretty much all of the time.  Well, here, literally anything can happen at any time.  You can have people going the wrong way down the road, pulling U-turns in the middle of the "lane," cutting across boundaries, driving on the shoulder, jumping onto and off of buses, etc.  So horns are basically constantly blowing.  You just have to determine how close they are being blown to you.  And if it is close, you better see what's going on.

This also makes it very difficult if you are looking for something because you need to be so aware of your immediate surroundings.  In fact, I was looking for something during my walk tonight.  And I didn't find it.

"But aren't there crosswalks?" you ask.  Crosswalks?  Crosswalks?!  Oh, sweet child.  So naive.

But really, this is why I'm here: to experience.  And this is part of it.  If crossing the street was not an adventure, I would have had nothing to write about tonight.

Sunday, February 5, 2012

India Begins

I've been in Hyderabad for over a week now.  Even in that little span of time, the experience has been amazing.  I have been spending the bulk of my time in the office, but I did get to tour the city a bit.

My first observation upon arriving at the airport was this:


I don't know why, but I love this picture.  I think it's because it represents the dichotomy of cultures here.

My first day in the office, the majority of the engineers in my department stopped by my office to introduce themselves with a big smile.  I really wasn't expecting that.  I've never had that happen in any other job.  But I thought it was really nice.

I met up with a friend of a friend and quickly became friends with her family.  The first day I met them, they invited me to be a groomsman in the eldest daughter's wedding!

I've always liked Indian food - both at home and in restaurants.  But eating the food here is just a whole new experience.  The tastes are different and everyone eats with their hands.  I have to say I really enjoy it, even though I'm very much a novice.  I'm always a little worried that I'm getting too much food on my hands.  Or that somehow my technique is offensive to the others at the table and they don't want to say anything about it.

This latter concern actually arises in a number of situations.  I don't know if I should take my shoes off upon entering a home.  I don't know if I'm addressing people in the proper manner.  This list goes on and on.  The problem is that views on these things vary by age group, religion, and probably a bunch of other factors.

I went to one day of the Telugu assembly this past weekend.  Here is a photo of lunch:

    
The brothers were super friendly.  I got to meet so many, even many who didn't speak much English.

Now we come to autorickshaws.  These things are simultaneously great and crazy.  Here is what they look like:


They are basically mopeds with three wheels and an outer shell.  They have one bench seat in the back and one seat for the driver.  Today I saw one with 8 adults.  I am not joking.  Here is a short clip of my ride in one going the wrong way on the street.  Just when it looks like he is going to turn and go in the proper lane, he turns and then goes the wrong way down that lane too:


Well, there is a lot more to say about India so far, but I'll stop here for now.

Thursday, January 26, 2012

My Project List

I have a terrible memory. Over the past few years, random ideas for projects would pop into my head and then, just as quickly, pop out. It was frustrating. So here I'm going to put my future project list into writing... mostly so I don't forget it.

Wireless Power
One of the biggest hurdles in our current state of technology is energy - particularly portable access to it. Everything from cell phones to electric automobiles is currently at the mercy of battery capacity. So the solution is simple: we kill the Batman battery.

Nikola Tesla did some fantastic work on this concept.  And that was about a hundred years ago.  It is theoretically sound.  We just need to make it happen.

I imagine it will start with portable energy stations, distributing power over a limited radius.  For example, you could drive one up to a construction site to wirelessly power lights and tools.  Eventually, though, entire cities would be energized.  Devices would be registered on the power network and electricity usage would automatically be billed to the device's owner.

The Knowledge Stream
Again, I am frustrated by my poor memory.  But modern tools like the Internet are making memory less and less important.  It's easy to do a quick search on your phone to get the answer to something.  But there are still three problems: 

1) There is still non-trivial effort involved.  You need to have a connected device.  You need to type in your query and wade through results.   

2) This is a "pull" system.  You need to make the above effort to retreive the data, which may or may not actually exist. 

3) This type of search is still, despite current efforts, more syntactic than semantic.  In other words, when we have a query, we need to guess at the keywords and hope that they lead to a relevant result.  There is still no good search engine that understands like a human would.   

The Knowledge Stream solves these three issues.  I imagine it like a constant flow of knowledge available as humankind uncovers it.  Maybe we would have implants in our brains that connect us to it (a la The Matrix), but the implementation is secondary.  Whatever the mechanism, the Stream would solve these three issues:

1) The effort to find knowledge drops dramatically, making it essentially no more difficult than accessing one of our own memories. 

2) You would now have an alternative to seeking out knowledge.  You could simply subscribe to domains that interest you and receive a feed of new knowledge as others discover and "publish" it.

3) The knowledge is not stored as text, but in a format that emulates how concepts are stored in our brains.  So "questioning" becomes simply pattern matching and "learning" becomes simply copying the resultant pattern.  (See my post "Reading is Too Serial" ... hmm ... actually I didn't write that yet.  Ok, it's coming soon.)

Granted, this is a huge undertaking.  But once it is complete, it will accelerate tremendously the pace of scientific and technological progress.

Edit Feb 20, 2012: Google is starting this 
Edit Mar 12, 2012: Getting closer to understanding memory encoding
Edit May 7, 2012: This is really gonna happen

Warp Drive
This was my original project idea.  I have listed it last because I think it will require the previous two to be functional before it becomes probable. 

I'm assuming we all are familiar with warp drive from Star Trek.  If not: it is an engine that allows for faster-than-light travel.  Given the size of our universe, warp drive will be necessary to travel in any meaningful way throughout it. 

So there's the list.  I don't want to attach time estimates to any of the projects because they would be completely arbitrary.  But I'm thinking the three could keep me busy for a thousand years at least.  Anyone want to help?

Thursday, January 12, 2012

The Jevons Paradox

It seems like a good idea at first glance.  Low-fat cookies.  So you buy them.  But because they low-fat, you eat more of them than you would have if they were high-fat.  So your total fat intake actually ends up being more.

This is the Jevons Paradox.

http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2010/12/20/101220fa_fact_owen

Jevons frames the concept, though, in terms of energy efficiency.  If you are running low on a resource, it seems to make sense to be more efficient in its use.  However, that increased efficiency leads to a net increase in use:

The problem with efficiency gains is that we inevitably reinvest them in additional consumption.

Of course, it's not bad to increase efficiency. It often leads to reduced costs or greater output. But it won't lead to reduced consumption.