Friday, July 6, 2012

There Is No Higgs Boson

The scientific community is astir this week as CERN may have found the Higgs Boson.  This is a theoretical particle thought to be what gives matter mass.  It is has been predicted by the Standard Model of Quantum Mechanics, but has yet to be observed.

CERN has been cautiously optimistic, but is clear that much more testing needs to be done to confirm.

So many have been asking this week: exactly how does the Higgs give mass to other particles?  You can check out a simple answer here:

http://simple.wikipedia.org/wiki/Higgs_field

The even simpler answer is that this particle interacts with the so-called Higgs Field.  The Higgs Field exists everywhere in the universe.  The field somehow converts some of the potential energy of the particle to what we perceive as mass.

So: there is an invisible field throughout the universe that allows mass to happen.

Does this sound familiar?  It should.

About a hundred years ago, a surprisingly similar idea existed: ether.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luminiferous_aether

This theory stated that light was able to travel across the universe because (surprise!) there is an invisible field throughout the universe that allows it to happen.  The now-famous Michelson-Morley experiment basically disproved it.

But here we are again.  Again, we can't understand how something works and so are attributing it to some pervasive, universal, invisible field.  Really, guys?

I'll be honest: I never liked the Standard Model with its Higgs Field.  I think it is inelegant, non-deterministic, and overly complicated.  But can I really say that the Higgs Boson doesn't exist and that the Standard Model is wrong?  No, I guess I can't.  I just wanted an attention-grabbing title to this post.

But I can say that it just feels wrong.  Of course, that is unscientific, but it's all I have at this point.  I suspect that, eventually, these physicists will realize that they didn't find the Higgs.  And then that the Standard Model is the wrong model.  That would be a good thing, because it would open the floor to strange, new models... one of which may be correct.

Thursday, June 14, 2012

The Knowledge Stream Keeps Inching Closer

I first mentioned the Knowledge Stream in my project list post.  In case you didn't get to read about it, the Knowledge Stream is a network of neural implants.  The idea is that all human knowledge could be shared instantaneously, without being restricted to a certain language.  The Stream would contain representations of information and concepts in a form mirroring that of your brain itself.

Anyone could subscribe to any feed of knowledge and get updates as they are published.  Likewise, anyone could search the Stream simply by thinking about the question or topic.

Anyway, the reason I'm writing about it again is because since the last post, there have been so many articles that are related to this.  They each cover a piece of the technology required.  Here is the latest one in which researchers created neural implants that are powered by your own body chemistry:

http://www.pcmag.com/article2/0,2817,2405796,00.asp

I'm telling you, it's going to happen!

Sunday, May 27, 2012

Spain Is Too Big to Fail - But It Will

There has been a lot of focus on Greece's financial state lately.  And rightly so, because its total debt (including unfunded liabilities) is about 11 times its GDP.

But, realistically, Greece's economy has never added much value to the European Union.  The EU had a GDP of about 12 trillion euro in 2010.  Greece only contributed 230 billion euro, or less than 2%.

Spain, however, is the weakest of the big contributors.  Its GDP was 1.6 trillion, or 13% of the EU.  And Spain has debt and unfunded liabilities totaling 6 times its GDP.

To put things in perspective, the US had debt equal to about 2 times its GDP in 1929... and we all know it took the Great Depression to unwind that debt.

So what's the point?  Spain will default.  And its economy is too big for the EU to save it.

In fact, its key index is already poised for a crash.  Notice the head and shoulders pattern in the IBEX:


Spain will likely trigger the EU collapse.  And that will then trigger a global collapse.  After all, US debt is currently 8 times its GDP:


Yep.

Saturday, April 28, 2012

The Age of Spin

They call it the Information Age.  And it is certainly an appropriate designation.  The amount of information available at our fingertips today is unprecedented.  You can answer any question by pulling your phone out of your pocket and clicking around a bit.  Thirty years ago this would have been an impossible dream.

Unfortunately, directly proportional to the increase in information is the increase in "spin."  Spin, as commonly defined, is presenting something in a particularly biased manner.  This results in most people seeing it differently than they would have had it been presented clearly and directly.

This is an election year in the US, so there is spin all over the place.  But even without presidential candidates competing to see who can deceive the greater number of citizens, spin is extremely prevalent today.

For example, let's take a tobacco company and use some made up numbers.  Let's say that the number of cigarette-related deaths has been increasing by an average of 10% a year for the past 30 years.  But last year, they only increased by 5%.  A tobacco company could say, then, that "the growth of cigarette-related death rates is decreasing."  If you saw that quote in a newspaper, you might think that cigarettes are getting safer.  Or, even, that they already are safer.

Is the tobacco company lying?  No.  Are they being dishonest?  Yes.

One might object here and say that they are not being dishonest - that they are actually saying what is true.  Indeed, they are saying what is true.  But they are intentionally phrasing it in a way that would mislead the majority.  That, too, is dishonesty.

Of course, statistics can always be manipulated to support some side of an argument.  But if you demand to see all of the numbers, you can draw your own conclusions.  It becomes trickier when there are no numbers.

This "spin without numbers" can probably best be illustrated by what a lawyer may do on cross-examination.  Some witness presents a very powerful testimony against the defendant.  The defendant's lawyer intentionally poses questions to the witness to weaken his testimony, even if the lawyer really knows inside that the witness is correct.  That is the lawyer's job: to spin.

And here we arrive at the reason why people spin: it is because they care more about their position than the truth.  In the lawyer's case, his position means his paycheck.  So of course he cares about it more than the truth.  For a corporation, its position also means its paycheck.  For other entities, pride could be the reason why they value their position more.  Of course, in an ideal world none of these reasons would take precedence over truth.  

So, back to the Information Age.  A presidential candidate, corporation, or any entity with some position to defend knows that they cannot control the flow of information today.  Information will get out to the public.  So they try to control the spin of that information.  Whichever side can spin it better will win.

This is extremely harmful for all involved.  First, there are those who are deceived by the spin.  Obviously, they are hurt by developing a very biased opinion.  But even those who are not deceived are hurt.  They develop a cynical attitude toward any information.  They view everything as potential spin.  They essentially become calloused to all data and distrustful of any viewpoint.

For example, whenever I read of some scientific study, I always find myself asking 'where did the funding for this study come from?'  That single question, even without an answer, is enough to cast doubt on the validity of the results.  

It is certainly discouraging to see what should be a triumph of technology and knowledge marred by the agendas of powerful people and organizations.  One would think that information ubiquity would reduce dishonesty, but in fact we are seeing quite the opposite.  Imperfect humans will always find a way to be dishonest for selfish reasons.

And, as mentioned, this hurts everyone.


Sunday, March 18, 2012

What We Want

I used to think that what we like and want is a deeply personal thing.  That it is something we think about and on which we make a conscious decision.  But after having lived in India for about 2 months, I'm realizing that is not at all the case.

When one arrives in India, it is immediately apparent that behavioral norms, customs, processes, priorities, and aspirations are very different than in the western hemisphere.  That's expected.  But what's interesting is that they like it that way.

For example, let's take a conversation I just had last night.  Where I come from, it is every kid's dream to move out on their own as soon as they become a young adult.  They want their own place and general independence.  In India, that would be viewed as disowning one's family and is thus a very negatively perceived practice.  But young people here want to stay with their families, oftentimes even after they are married.

So what's going on here?  How can one entire society want one thing and another want the opposite?  If what we want is indeed a personal choice, this is not what we would expect.  We would expect a random distribution within each society.

The only reasonable explanation is that what we want is really not our own decision but is largely shaped by our environment.  Perhaps we do have some flexibility within that framework, but we like the framework as a whole because it is what we are used to.

Is this a good thing or a bad thing?  I'm going to go out on a limb and say it's a bad thing.  In fact, I'll generalize and say that anytime we choose something implicitly, without truly thinking about it, it's a bad thing.  And that is exactly what we are doing when we choose to like something simply because our environment tells us it's the norm.  

Let me be clear: I am not saying that one or the other view in my example above is good or bad.  I'm saying it's bad to choose one simply because our environment tells us to.

There are some people who buck the trend of choosing to like what their environment dictates.  These are generally viewed as pioneers, visionaries and revolutionaries.  Sometimes they are viewed as heretics and terrorists.  This viewpoint, too, is often determined by the environment.

After arriving here, I was forced to examine for myself why I like or want certain things.  What I found was that I, too, had implicitly chosen things based on what my society expected.  I also found that, even after realizing such, it is a very difficult thing to change what I like and want.  Perhaps I haven't yet encountered sufficient reason to do so.  Not sure.

So what is the point?  I'm afraid I don't really have one.  But I think it's important to realize the depth at which our society can shape us.  At least for me, it is deeper than I thought.